Certificate of Pending Litigation (CPL) in British Columbia
Real property disputes in British Columbia often involve urgent concerns about ownership, title, and the ability to transfer or encumber land. When a legal dispute affects an interest in land, the law provides a powerful tool that can preserve the status quo until the court resolves the underlying claim. This tool is known as a Certificate of Pending Litigation. A Certificate of Pending Litigation is one of the most significant remedies available in real estate litigation because it restricts the owner’s ability to sell, mortgage, or otherwise deal with the property. It can protect a claimant’s interest, but it can also impose serious consequences for property owners.
This article provides a detailed and practical explanation of Certificates of Pending Litigation in British Columbia. It examines the legal framework, the process for obtaining and cancelling a Certificate of Pending Litigation, the strategic considerations for both claimants and property owners, and the litigation issues that frequently arise.
What Is a Certificate of Pending Litigation
A Certificate of Pending Litigation is a document registered against the title of real property to give notice that the property is the subject of a legal claim. It is governed by the Land Title Act. The purpose of a Certificate of Pending Litigation is to preserve the property until the court determines the rights of the parties. It does not determine ownership, but it prevents the owner from transferring clear title.
A Certificate of Pending Litigation is often described as a form of security. It ensures that the property remains available to satisfy a judgment or to enforce a claim to ownership. Because real property is often the most valuable asset involved in a dispute, the Certificate of Pending Litigation is a critical tool for protecting a claimant’s interest.
When Can a Certificate of Pending Litigation Be Registered
A Certificate of Pending Litigation can be registered only when a legal proceeding has been commenced in the Supreme Court of British Columbia and the claim relates to an interest in land. The claimant must file a Notice of Civil Claim that asserts a claim to an estate or interest in the property. Examples of claims that may support a Certificate of Pending Litigation include:
Claims for ownership of the property
Claims for specific performance of a contract for the sale of land
Claims involving constructive trusts or resulting trusts
Claims involving fraudulent conveyances
Claims involving co ownership disputes
Claims involving matrimonial property or family property
Claims involving easements or rights of way
A Certificate of Pending Litigation cannot be registered for claims that do not relate to an interest in land. For example, a claim for unpaid money, without more, does not justify a Certificate of Pending Litigation.
The Process for Registering a Certificate of Pending Litigation
The process for registering a Certificate of Pending Litigation involves several steps:
Step One: Filing a Notice of Civil Claim
The claimant must commence a legal proceeding in the Supreme Court of British Columbia. The Notice of Civil Claim must plead a claim to an interest in land. The court will not permit a Certificate of Pending Litigation if the claim does not relate to land.
Step Two: Filing an Application for a Certificate of Pending Litigation
The claimant files an application in the court registry requesting issuance of a Certificate of Pending Litigation. The application must be supported by the Notice of Civil Claim.
Step Three: Registration in the Land Title Office
Once the court issues the Certificate of Pending Litigation, the claimant registers it in the Land Title Office. Registration creates a public record that the property is the subject of litigation.
Once registered, the Certificate of Pending Litigation prevents the owner from transferring clear title. Any purchaser or lender will see the Certificate of Pending Litigation on title and will be unable to complete a transaction unless the Certificate of Pending Litigation is cancelled.
The Effect of a Certificate of Pending Litigation
A Certificate of Pending Litigation has significant consequences for property owners. It does not transfer ownership, but it restricts the owner’s ability to deal with the property. The most important effects include:
Restriction on Sale
A property subject to a Certificate of Pending Litigation cannot be sold with clear title. Most buyers will not proceed with a purchase unless the Certificate of Pending Litigation is removed.
Restriction on Financing
Lenders generally refuse to provide financing or refinancing when a Certificate of Pending Litigation is registered on title. This can place significant financial pressure on the owner.
Impact on Property Value
A Certificate of Pending Litigation may reduce the marketability of the property. Buyers may be unwilling to wait for litigation to resolve.
Preservation of the Claimant’s Interest
For the claimant, the Certificate of Pending Litigation ensures that the property remains available to satisfy a judgment or to enforce a claim to ownership.
Because of these consequences, a Certificate of Pending Litigation is a powerful strategic tool in litigation.
When a Certificate of Pending Litigation Is Appropriate
A Certificate of Pending Litigation is appropriate when the claimant seeks to protect an interest in land. Examples include:
Disputes Between Co Owners
Co owners may disagree about the use, sale, or management of the property. A Certificate of Pending Litigation can preserve the property until the dispute is resolved.
Claims of Beneficial Ownership
A claimant may assert that the legal owner holds the property in trust for the claimant. A Certificate of Pending Litigation protects the claimant’s alleged beneficial interest.
Fraudulent Conveyance Claims
If a property is transferred to avoid creditors, a Certificate of Pending Litigation can prevent further transfers.
Contract Disputes Involving Real Estate
If a seller refuses to complete a sale, the buyer may seek specific performance and register a Certificate of Pending Litigation to prevent the seller from selling to someone else.
Cancelling a Certificate of Pending Litigation
A Certificate of Pending Litigation can be cancelled in several ways. The most common methods include:
Cancellation by Court Order
The property owner may apply to the court to cancel the Certificate of Pending Litigation. The court may cancel it if:
The claim does not relate to an interest in land
The claim is without merit
The claimant has not prosecuted the claim diligently
The owner posts security in place of the Certificate of Pending Litigation
The court has discretion to cancel a Certificate of Pending Litigation if it is oppressive or if the claimant is using it improperly.
Cancellation by Consent
The parties may agree to cancel the Certificate of Pending Litigation. This often occurs when the dispute is resolved or when the claimant accepts security in place of the property.
Cancellation After Dismissal of the Claim
If the court dismisses the underlying claim, the Certificate of Pending Litigation must be cancelled.
Posting Security in Place of a Certificate of Pending Litigation
In some cases, the court may order cancellation of a Certificate of Pending Litigation if the owner posts security. Security may take the form of:
A payment into court
A letter of credit
A lien or charge on another property
Posting security allows the owner to sell or refinance the property while preserving the claimant’s potential recovery.
Abuse of Certificates of Pending Litigation
Although Certificates of Pending Litigation are important tools, they can be misused. Courts in British Columbia have recognized that some claimants attempt to use Certificates of Pending Litigation to pressure property owners into settlement. Because a Certificate of Pending Litigation can block a sale or refinancing, it can create significant leverage.
Courts will cancel a Certificate of Pending Litigation if it is used for an improper purpose or if the underlying claim is weak or unrelated to land. Claimants must ensure that their claims are legitimate and that they are not using the Certificate of Pending Litigation as a tactic to obtain an unfair advantage.
Strategic Considerations for Claimants
Claimants should consider the following before registering a Certificate of Pending Litigation:
Whether the claim genuinely relates to an interest in land
Whether the Certificate of Pending Litigation is necessary to protect the claim
Whether the claimant is prepared to prosecute the claim diligently
Whether the claimant is prepared for potential applications to cancel the Certificate of Pending Litigation
A Certificate of Pending Litigation can be a powerful tool, but it must be used responsibly.
Strategic Considerations for Property Owners
Property owners who discover a Certificate of Pending Litigation on title should consider the following:
Whether the claim is valid
Whether the claimant has pleaded an interest in land
Whether the owner should apply to cancel the Certificate of Pending Litigation
Whether posting security is appropriate
Whether the dispute can be resolved through negotiation
Because a Certificate of Pending Litigation can significantly affect the owner’s ability to deal with the property, prompt legal advice is essential.
Conclusion
Certificates of Pending Litigation are among the most powerful remedies available in British Columbia real estate litigation. They preserve property while the court determines the rights of the parties, but they also impose serious restrictions on property owners. Understanding when a Certificate of Pending Litigation is appropriate, how it is registered, and how it can be cancelled is essential for anyone involved in a property dispute.
Queenstone Law represents both claimants and property owners in litigation involving the registration, defence, and cancellation of Certificates of Pending Litigation. We assist clients with applications to register a Certificate of Pending Litigation, applications to cancel a Certificate of Pending Litigation, and disputes involving misuse or improper registration. Contact us here.
NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Information made available on the Queenstone Law website in any form is for information purposes only. It is not legal advice. You should not rely on, or take or fail to take any action, based upon this information. We would be pleased to discuss any specific legal concerns you may have.
Although we attempt to keep the information on our site accurate and up-to-date, due to the ever changing nature of the law, as well as, the speed at which new cases are released, we cannot guarantee that the content is fully up to date or remains completely accurate.